Best 6 Aussie Ford Muscle Cars vs. Holden's best 6 Muscle Cars

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 09:57 PM

I'm conducting a poll to find out the top 6 Ford and Holden aussie muscle cars blokes would like to drive the most.

I have a bet with my mate that they would be as follows:

1. XY GT
2. XB GT coupe
3. XC Cobra
4. XE ESP 351
5. FPV F6
6. FPV GT

1. Torana A9X Hatch
2. Brock VK Group A
3. Torana XU1
4. Walkinshaw VL
5. Monaro HG
6. HSV VS GTS-R

I'm keen to find out what others reckon coz he owes me 4 slabs of beer of I win.

4Vman · 30-03-2010, 10:10 PM

1. XY GTHO H3
2. XW GTHO H2
3. XA GT Coupe with RPO 83
4. XBGT 73 bigport manual
5. XRGT (the beginning of it all)
6. FG MK2 Coyote S/C FPV GT (yeah i know, not really a musclecar and not out yet)!

1. HT 350 GTS Monaro
2. A9X Hatch
3. Torana XU1
4. L34 Sedan
5. HK 327 GTS Monaro
6. VK Group A (not really a musclecar but cool as hell)

Iggypoppin' · 30-03-2010, 10:19 PM

XB GT
T3TS50(manual)
F6
XYGT
XRGT

my pick

and holden

A9X Torana
VS GTSR
VK G3
Monaro Coupe 4(2004 model i think?)
HX Monaro.

Rodp · 30-03-2010, 10:24 PM

Don't like your chances. What does he win?

The FPV's would be well down my list. Same with the VL and VS. 4 cars I had the opportunity to buy and didn't.

1. XWGT P2
2. XYGT P3
3. XAGT P4 (does it have to be production...?)
4. XRGT
5. XBGT

1. W427
2. L34 SL/R5000
3. XU1
4. A9X
5. HT 350 Monaro

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 10:24 PM

4Vman you have the yet to be released FG MK2 in your top 6 ! My mate has too! He also has the XR GT! His looks like this:

1. XR GT
2. XY GT
3. XB Coupe (Mad Max style)
4. XE ESP
5. EL GT
6. FG Mk2 Supercharged

His Holdens are similar:
1.L34 Sedan
2. LX Monaro (??) ha?
3. VL Brock HDT Grp A
4. A9X Hatch
5. HK Monaro
6. Walkinshaw VL

Maybe it all depends on when you grew up...

SVD · 30-03-2010, 10:25 PM

XA GTHO
XY GTHO
T3TS50
EL GT
T3 TL50
F6

And for Holden

XU1 Torana
W427 (i know its ugly and crap but i wanna see what that motor can do...)
VS GTS-R
VL Walkinshaw
VN GrpA SS
HSV Coupe60

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 10:27 PM

ok looks like im buying the beers at this stage!
the SLR5000 would be cool....

the T3 was one I was not expecting... Id love to drive one of those...

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 10:28 PM

hey SVD glad to see u included an ELGT! I agree : )

Iggypoppin' · 30-03-2010, 10:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wild High

4Vman you have the yet to be released FG MK2 in your top 6 ! My mate has too! He also has the XR GT! His looks like this:

1. XR GT
2. XY GT
3. XB Coupe (Mad Max style)
4. XE ESP
5. EL GT
6. FG Mk2 Supercharged

His Holdens are similar:
1.L34 Sedan
2. LX Monaro (??) ha?
3. VL Brock HDT Grp A
4. A9X Hatch
5. HK Monaro
6. Walkinshaw VL

Maybe it all depends on when you grew up...

or maybe which era you are from...

i am being raised in the day and age of the BA falcon and onwards, so the cars in my list reflect that. obviously, i included the torana because i acknowledge it as a true muscle car, and the VK for that reason too, the XB is a no brainer but then i've been lucky enough to drive one and have a connection with them, the VS i acknowledge was a serious machine when it came out(GTSR) and was very rare too(still is) as is the TS50. the F6 is a no brainer, its very fast, already has a bit of a cult following and just because its a 6, doesnt mean it can't be a muscle car. there is no set in stone law that dictates that muscle cars must be V8's. the XRGT was the first ever GT and as such paved ford's way...another no brainer. my explenation for old and new in my list, just remember, when Phase 3's etc etc where new, they where probably considered "too new school" for all the old heads with the flathead V8's and such and such. everything is new at some stage

4Vman · 30-03-2010, 10:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wild High

4Vman you have the yet to be released FG MK2 in your top 6 ! ...

Yeah i know, strictly speaking not a musclecar and not out yet but i just cant wait to drive one, its going to kick butt.

FG XR · 30-03-2010, 10:37 PM

XY GTHO PH3
XA GTHO PH4
EA GT 351 (Hey would have being cool as hell i bet!)
TS50
FPV F6 R Spec
FPV GTHO PH5 *cough* :thebirds:

Torana A9X
Torana SLR5000
XU1
VL Walkinshaw
VS GTS-R
W427

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 10:37 PM

iggypoppin - luvd the feedback. i grew up mostly in the 80's, however my dad had an XY during the 70's (im 38 yo)
so my fondest memories stretch over a longer period.
i love the 70's and 80's cars as a result, however as more than a decade has passed since the 90's, Im starting to reflect more fondly on the 90's muscle cares. Personally I loved the XR8 Sprint, the EB GT and EL GT era. The E series are starting to look a bit retro now... and kinda cool and tuff.

SVD · 30-03-2010, 10:39 PM

i wish it could be more then 6, i know one ford i'd really like to try, but couldn't bring myself to remove any others for, would be the EL Predator... that would be a very nice car to drive... Supercharged I6 mmmm

Iggypoppin' · 30-03-2010, 10:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wild High

iggypoppin - luvd the feedback. i grew up mostly in the 80's, however my dad had an XY during the 70's (im 38 yo)
so my fondest memories stretch over a longer period.
i love the 70's and 80's cars as a result, however as more than a decade has passed since the 90's, Im starting to reflect more fondly on the 90's muscle cares. Personally I loved the XR8 Sprint, the EB GT and EL GT era. The E series are starting to look a bit retro now... and kinda cool and tuff.

im twenty, so my only memories are of dads VS SS-when you're 7 or 8 and dad comes home with the brand new V8, you wet your pants just looking at it. back then he talked about the GTSR and how, if he had the money, he'd have got one. it stuck!! when i finally read up on it, i knew it was the goods.

same with the TS50. too late in the AU stable it reared its head, yet with a 250kw stroker engine, it cemented its(small) place in the muscle car history books..at least for me.

the XB GT is my favourite, of course. i was 13 when dad's mate owned it and took me for a spin. i was never more in love(and i still have the photos!) and still am. number one for me.

the other cars, i believe, are just deserving of the spots i gave them. just opinion though!

Windsor220 · 30-03-2010, 10:45 PM

Dont think the XE ESP should rate in there. Just a Fairmont V8 with modded suspension isnt it? 16 second quarter mile.

AMCE · 30-03-2010, 10:54 PM

fair point windsor. however it was still the basis for Dick Johnsons famous Greens Tuf XE and the only Ford muscle car of the 80's.
I own one, and you would be amazed at the level of interest in the XE ESP...
also dont forget it was the last of the big bangers - the 5.8 litre 351 Clevo!!

Windsor220 · 30-03-2010, 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wild High

fair point windsor. however it was still the basis for Dick Johnsons famous Greens Tuf XE and the only Ford muscle car of the 80's.
I own one, and you would be amazed at the level of interest in the XE ESP...
also dont forget it was the last of the big bangers - the 5.8 litre 351 Clevo!!

Yeah no doubt its one of the collectables. Just dont think it would be in the top 6.

My list
XR GT
XY GTHO Phase 3
XA GTHO Phase 4
XC Cobra Bathurst Special
AU T3 TS50
FPV FG F6

Honourable mentions: XW GTHO Phase 2, EB XR6, ED XR8 sprint, EL GT and the yet to be released FPV FG GT supercharged 5.0

SVD · 30-03-2010, 11:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Windsor220

Dont think the XE ESP should rate in there. Just a Fairmont V8 with modded suspension isnt it? 16 second quarter mile.

and a different interior and body moldings and what not, there was actually a fair bit of work that went into ESP's more then just a Ghia with a sticker pack...

i mean some could argue the XC Cobra was just a V8 with a sticker pack...

Iggypoppin' · 30-03-2010, 11:39 PM

unfortunatly, the ESP had a whole host of emissions control gear bolted onto its 351...a sad and sorry fate for the hailed cleveland.

BENT_8 · 31-03-2010, 12:15 AM

For me...

XA GTHO 4
ZC Fairlane 'T'
XB GT Coupe
XC Cobra
XE ESP 5.8
FG2 Coyote

HQ GTS350 Sedan
XU1 Bathurst pack
A9X
HZ GTS
HQ Statesman 350
VN GrpA SS

XDV800 · 31-03-2010, 12:36 AM

Ford;

XW Phase 2 GTHO
XY Phase 3 GTHO
XC Cobra 'Bathurst'
ED XR8 Sprint
EL GT
BF FPV Cobra

Holden;

HT GTS Monaro 350
A9X Torana
VL Director (with option motor)
VN Group A SS
VS GTS-R
W427

My list is based on available to the showroom, factory cars.
Need a a list of 1 offs/prototypes/authorised 'special vehicle' cars as well i reckon, just to spice it up a bit.

geckoGT · 31-03-2010, 12:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BENT_8

For me...

XA GTHO 4
ZC Fairlane 'T'
XB GT Coupe
XC Cobra
XE ESP 5.8
FG2 Coyote

HQ GTS350 Sedan
XU1 Bathurst pack
A9X
HZ GTS
HQ Statesman 350
VN GrpA SS

Not sure how you can not have the XY GTHO Ph3 in your list (the greatest muscle car in aussie history), but hey it is your list.

I am going to go with.

XR GT (the genesis)
XW GTHO
XY GTHO Ph3
XB GT Coupe
XC Cobra
XE ESP (based more on DJR than road models)

I have not put down the FG Coyote because it does not exist yet, I also have not included cars that did not hit production, as far as I am concerned only "have been" should count, not could have been. I have also not counted any F6 as to me they are not really a "muscle car".

Holden.

HK GTS 327 (Holdens first attack against ford and the beginning of the war)
HG GTS 350 (the last of the true monaro's)
L34
A9X
VK Grp A
W427

BENT_8 · 31-03-2010, 01:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by geckoGT

Not sure how you can not have the XY GTHO Ph3 in your list (the greatest muscle car in aussie history), but hey it is your list.

I've got the Ph4, considering the PH3 is superior to the PH2, the PH4 one would assume is...

geckoGT · 31-03-2010, 01:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BENT_8

I've got the Ph4, considering the PH3 is superior to the PH2, the PH4 one would assume is...

I guess so, just depends how you look at it I suppose. I have not considered cars that were not actually released.

To do so would require the inclusion of cars such as the Holden Hurricane and XU2 Torana.

SVD · 31-03-2010, 01:19 AM

well technically the PH4 was released... there was one built and it wasn't a prototype so it kind of is a legit model...

BENT_8 · 31-03-2010, 01:45 AM

Correct, the Ph4 was released, unfortunately it never got a shot at the title...

Boosh Brus · 31-03-2010, 11:13 AM

XB GT Coupe
XA GT Coupe
XW GTHO P2
XC Cobra
Landau
XP Coupe

And

HK GTS
HG GTS
HQ GTS
A9X
If the list is just drive then XU1 if its to own then maybe W427 cant picture myself with a XU1
Maybe a VK Brock

gcg2503 · 31-03-2010, 11:22 AM

I am very surprised by the number of times that XB GTs have popped up in peoples lists!

AMCE · 31-03-2010, 11:29 AM

keep em coming fellas....
im really surprised with the XB GT too. I will collate all the feedback and do a final analysis.

I'd like to get a few more responses before putting it together.

gcg2503 · 31-03-2010, 11:38 AM

XA GT P4
XY GT P3
XW GT Bill Bourke 428 (sure its an auto but who cares)
XC Cobra 351 Bathurst Special
XE ESP 351
XA GT RPO83

HQ 350 Monaro Coupe
HT GTS Bathurst Special 350
LX A9X
HK GTS 327 Monaro
LH SLR5000
VL BT1 in canary Yellow complete with blowoff valaves and mismatching rear stockies